March 30th, 2010 by soullldiva

In a follow-up to my post about big changes on So You Think You Can Dance, producer and judge Nigel Lythgoe held his press conference via phone yesterday.

Here’s the big change:

The reason that there will not be a top 20, only a top 10 is that the top 10 contestants will be paired with dancers from past seasons of So You Think You Can Dance. WHOA! WHAT?

I am so conflicted on how to think about this. On one hand, I love the pairings, the camraderie, the melding of two personalities into one duo. And I also love seeing so many dancers and their individualities as they develop and bloom into even better dancers and artists. On the other hand, the show would no longer be So You Think You Can Dance. It would morph into So You Think You Can Dance With the Stars (stars being the past pro dancers who now have celebrity status).

I do love the past contestants, It would be really cool to see them again after they have been out “in the real world” for some time. What have they been doing? Have they increased their skills? Are they as personable as before (or limp dishrags)?

A change this big can only signal one thing in my mind: the show is having troubles with ratings. This will most certainly boost it. But for how long? I don’t know if I like the change, I will have to experience it in season 7. But I sincerely HOPE that it WORKS. I want to keep dance on national television, so that it can continue to influence us–give us that injection of aesthetics, art and creation that this world needs so desperately.

Nigel, you’re playing your hand–will So You Think You Can Dance win? I hope so.